interesting post!
where can i buy a tin of this, cheers!
my view is & in agreement what rod hutchinson wrote all those years ago in: The carp strikes back...with 1 addition below*
ie what i bloded in ya post "was missing from their food, carp would search out foods that provided all the nutrients they required"
back then when most carpers made home-baits....most lakes get hammered with the going bait, early 80's semo-soya-flour sweeter flavor....once results started to flatter, someone tries protein AND cleans up! all get on to protein...at some point results decline, fish meal come alone, then meat, liver, then tigers, then hemp etc, etc ...a constant ongoing cycle...
case in point, do ya remember the story about andy little on savay....he was spending a FORTUNE on protein, his results were TOP NOTCH ...however he couldn't afford the expense with the amount of protein he was paying out for, so he decided to do a test and substitute the milk-protein for semo-soya-flour mix ONLY using the same flavor as in the successful milk-protein, to his amazement he got the same successful results!
* I believe carp have *ADDICTIONS* just like us lol
who can resit eating a bag of cheddar cheese & onion crisps even knowing its c r a p junk-food?
...i open a 150G bag only want to eat a few BUT...end up scoffing the lot down in 1 sitting!
its simply an addiction to those TASTY crisps even though you can eat bags AND still not feel full!
If you look at the last 25 years the BIG NAMED brand commercial carp boilies sold, NONE are HNV...YET they WORK quite well don't they?
I reckon the recipe guys behind the BIG brand commercial carp boilies are making bait based on the above*...of course imo.