Nick i agree that some anglers do reach for a choddy ( sorry ) because it is the easy option and not always the correct "tool" for the job , myself included at times .
Your post above Nick , is that why you are dead against its use in weed ?
I have been reading some old threads , many going back a lot of years , and you have been saying the same throughout all that time which is to your credit because you are consistent and people often are not .
But you are the only person i've ever "met" who is of that opinion .
In actual fact , one of the Chase lakes has weed from surface to lakebed all over and everybody i has asked , recommends a "long choddy" whatever that means ?
I think if you was to poll this forum about the use of silt rigs in weed the result , rightly or wrongly , would be a resounding YES .
On the back chase lake that i fish the lakebed HAS gravel but is largely shallow silt covered in what they call Filamous Algae and the rig works very well . Would you say that was using it in weed ?
I would never infer that you might be wrong mate , too much respect for your knowledge and experience for that , but why do you think nobody else has picked up on it ?