I think option 1 will work better, more often, whether they suck or bite.
On the underwater films most fish come in at an angle, not straight down, when they are feeding. The angle of the hook in option 1 is more likely to hit flesh after a good suck and blow ( ) as well as if the fish come straight in and clamp down on the bait, in my opinion.
Ddg, can you fish option 1 and option 2, side by side to compare results?