I also hate the term quick overnighter lol
i also don’t care how long the shelter takes to put up so when they say it only takes less than a minute to put up that really doesn’t interest me It takes me longer than that to get all the bits out of the bags and then it would be the last thing to go up if at all, i get all the head room I want with nothing over the top. I just want covering if it’s going to rain lol
tend to get less bothered by mozzies also I find.
back to your problem.
If you barrow all the kit around then yep it probably really doesn’t matter
if you carry it then it does.
im afraid it’s going to be which one suits you best
good Luck with whatever one you choose 👍
Ps
never seen the ninja rods but I use the ninja reels and I really like them
I also have a set of the shimano tx compact 4 piece but in 12foot 2.5tc