I would say I have caught more big fish in the past ten years using a short rod, centre pin and float than any other method, I love watching fish on the move and placing a bait in their path, a real adrenalin buzz.
I think experienced anglers will always look to do a bit of stalking when they can, be it floaters or on the deck.
One thing I don't look at with rose tinted glasses is the rubbish tackle he uses, thank goodness that side has progressed, I'd give up if that was my set-up, useless.