I am glad to here from you "andypalf" and I can see what your saying . I tweak my rigs if its needed in a particular circumstance, but i feel that the most of the time, a sharp hook on the simplest of rigs can catch more carp than a rig that has loads of fashionable bits on it weighing the hook down. i too, am somewhat of a tackle tart as i like messing around with the rigs and buying all of the fancy bits, but 9 times out of 10 ,in my fishing ,i catch more carp on simple rigs. i personally feel that the less there is on the hook the less chance there is of the fish picking it out from the crowd. i am a big fan of the "d-rig" mind as i like the way the bottom bait can hide the hook when its on the deck and the amount of movement the bait has when the rig is picked up. I don't use the "D-rig" for its ejection properties but I would like to think that the ejection properties are as good as we are led to believe. I find it hard to believe the bait is the only thing ejected using that rig, especially when using smaller hooks like we use on our winter rigs as the size of the "D" is limited. sorry any way , just my thoughts