it depends what youre after? 20 or more carp in a day is easily achievable at melverly,so if you want a bend in your rod,and the chance of some perfect upper doubles,i wouldnt rule it out.last time i went my biggest was an 18 common.stunning fish and not a mark on it.that was my largest of a 12 fish session and was only there for a short session.
yeh normans wierd,but all he wants is the money in the box before you fish and hes happy ploughing muck in the next field for the rest of the day then.
and yeh,the 30 is a myth,but arent most day ticket places the same? theres always someone who knows someone whos had a monster out,and unless youre on a syndicate,where you know what the lake record is,youl never know unless youre lucky enough to hook it.
i have been literally hundreds of times,as like i say i used to live 2 mins away,and have seen some cracking lumps come out,and had many enjoyable sessions with my carp gear catching lots of carp. youve only been once and have drawn your conclusion by only catching 3 fish??
all i say is,go,give it a go,its not the worst place by any means,and i guarantee you will catch.if you want to sit it out for the bigguns,then yeh,wrekin res is probably a better shout,but when my syndicate rota isnt on my week on,i go sumwhere like melverly for a bit of a confidence boost and to see if my rigs that failed to catch a monster on my lake actualy work!!