I borrowed this quote (its only part of a reply) from the Different Strains thread, and its a subject that I've been thinking about as well.
There are definitely different ways of feeding from different Carp, it has come up in the past in this thread as well.
Some fish will suck and blow to eat their food, and others will scoop and pick up their food in the lips. Is this sucking and blowing fish going to get caught on the same rig as a fish which mouthes the bait?
How do you make a rig that will catch the both types of feeding.
Shorter rigs will catch fish that are over beds of bait, but will this same short rig catch fish feeding on this bait that are sucking the baits in? It can't be going in far enough. Is this the reason for hookpulls on some fish?
Or is the short rig being taken in by fish that are picking the bait up and the lead is pulling the hook down to pr1ck the fish too early?
On a longer rig with a good length hair ( both longer than usual) do both types of fish get caught?
The water I have had a problem with hookholds I was playing this week, and had takes on 2 different rigs, one again, slightly more Complicated than standard.
The rig that produced 3 fish was a Basic Knotless Knotted SuperNova Hooklink to ESP hook of about 20cm long. From the end of the bait I had about 10mm clearance to the shank.
The other rod had on a Coated Braid Snowman presentation on a Sliding ring on the shank of the hook, the ring only able to slide to the top of the shank as there was a small Fox rubber stop. I had no clearance from the bait to the ring, the hookbait was tight, no additional hair showing through the bait.
On both rigs the carp were hooked fairly and squarely and I had no problems with either.
Have I gone too Complicated to start with? Dave had a Carp on a basic Amnesia Hooklink with a mono hair.
Personnely I think the carp eating your bait has much more say so on whether or not you hook it. I think rigs only make a slight difference in comparrison.