Guys, these are all valid points, and well made. I'd guess that it's the circumstances (location, ambience, fishing with buddies, etc.) of catching a big carp that are what it's all about really... for me, I'd not want to catch a 50 pounder stock fish from a hole in the ground... but I've had many memorable days just stalking and sight-fishing for teens and twenties on the limestone flats of Lake Michigan... nothing between me and the horizon but a dorsal fin or three!
That's probably the main reason I moved to the US; carping is a big challenge here, but a different challenge from the UK or Western Europe. Here, every fish is wild, every water is enormous, and it's easy to find a good place to fish away from any other angler... I fish a couple of spots within 15 miles from my house where I have never ever seen another human being, every time I've been there it's been like the rest of mankind just doesn't exist!
And then there's the beauty of the waters... to make that first cast into some of these lakes is amazing... when you just know that you are the first person ever to fish for carp; it takes me back to the first carp I ever caught, to being a kid on my first trip to a new water, where everything is wonderful and 100% new...
Then there's the amazing contradiction that Wisconsin carping offers... the smaller fish (up to 30 pounders!) aren't that shy, but they are clever... generally the biggest problem is keeping away from the singles and teens long enough for a bigger fish to make up it's mind!
The final piece of the pie is the fish themselves... 90%+ have never even seen a hook before, and when you get connected they just panic and run, and run... and run! Because they are all wild stock (originally from Germany in the 1870's), they have a different body shape than farmed carp, much more streamlined, beautiful fish. And then you have the river carp, some of those guys look more like a Barbel on steriods... and they fight just like they look!
Every time I go fishing, I get that weird feeling... that this can't be real, I don't deserve all these fish, how can I be so lucky? It's truly like visiting carp heaven, every trip.
Oh, Pellethead, if you want to come over, you don't need to worry about the gear (although I fly my carp gear over every couple of years, normally costs an extra 50 pounds for the "long tube"!)... if you want to fish with me you are of course welcome to borrow some of my gear! It's still difficult on most days to fish with more than 1 rod, when the big girls start to feed... I've given up fishing 3 rods after playing 3 thirties at the same time... badly!